MADRID — A Spanish court on Friday dropped a criminal complaint brought against members of the Syrian security and intelligence forces by a woman seeking justice for her brother, ruling it lacked jurisdiction over the case.
The complaint was raised by a Spaniard who said her brother was arrested, tortured and executed in 2013 at a center in Damascus under the control of Syrian security forces.
The Spanish woman filed her case after identifying her brother from a cache of more than 50,000 photos smuggled out of the country by a Syrian forensics officer showing more than 6,000 people who had been tortured and mutilated.
A judge at the Madrid-based High Court agreed in March to investigate the lawsuit in March, the first case against Syrian security forces taken up overseas.
But a higher panel within the High Court ruled on Friday that the investigation should be dropped following an appeal by Spain’s state prosecutors.
The woman’s legal representatives, London-based Guernica 37, said they had not received any notification of the decision, but might lodge an appeal to the Spanish Supreme Court.
“This is a setback and we are of course disappointed, but this is just a step in the legal process. We remain confident in the strength of our case and the firm jurisdictional basis,” Guernica 37 said in a statement.
Under Spanish law, the examining magistrate investigates accusations brought in a criminal complaint before moving into a trial phase.
Spain was once a pioneer of “universal jurisdiction”, whereby judges could pursue criminal cases originating anywhere in the world. Spanish courts led investigations into human rights abuses in Argentina and Rwanda under this premise.
But the conservative government of Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy moved to curb these powers in 2014, arguing that they could cause diplomatic conflicts, and it passed the new limits through parliament.
Cases now must have a clear Spanish connection to proceed.
This article was originally published on 21st July 2017 at The New York Times.
Toby Cadman participates in the debate “Libya peace talks – can they...Read Story
State Dept. Office of Global Criminal Justice on the Chopping Block–Time to...Read Story
New York Times: “Spain Court Drops Complaint Against Syrian Security...Read Story
Report: Voices from the Dark. Torture and Sexual Violence Against Women in Assad...Read Story
Interview: Toby Cadman analyses the war crimes case filed against Syrian...Read Story
CNN: “The torture survivors suing the Syrian regime”Read Story
Statement of Former US Ambassador-at-Large for War Crimes Stephen Rapp on the...Read Story
Guernica37 files preliminary inquiry to investigate Mr. David Haigh’s...Read Story
Press Release: IBAHRI adopts Resolution on armed drone strikes amid major...Read Story
Estreno del documental “Eye of the Lammergeier” sobre el genocidio contra el...Read Story
The State of Qatar: Sovereign Nation or a Vassal StateRead Story
IONO fm: “UK activists demand end to Saudi Arabia, UAE arms sales”Read Story