Guernica 37
Guernica 37

The New York Times: “Rwanda Accuses France of Complicity in 1994 Genocide”

The New York Times reports that Rwandan authorities have urged the French Government to release classified documents and admit its alleged responsibility in the 1994 Rwanda genocide.

The request follows the release this week of the “Muse Report”, a document accusing France of assisting in the protection of Rwandan genocidaires and in the design of an ideological basis for the genocide in order to maintain its influence over the African continent. The report alleges that French authorities provided training, intelligence, and arms to the perpetrators of international crimes before, and during their attack against the Tutsi community.

The Muse report contradicts a previous 1998 report drafted by a French parliamentary commission, which found no evidence of French collaboration in the genocide. Moreover, according to Jina Moore, author of the article, French officials continue to undermine attempts to prosecute genocide suspects, and further, that this reluctance “has further aggravated” the already complicated situation between both countries.

Ms Mushikiwabo, Minister of Foreign Affairs for Rwanda, claims that there has been “a systematic cover-up and fabrication of a narrative to hide the traces of French military and political collaboration in the genocide”. According to the minister “France was part of the planning, part of the conception, and part of the execution of the genocide”.

The article cites co-founder of The Guernica Group, Toby Cadman, who made a comparative analysis with contemporary massacres and said the questions at play also had an impact on global affairs: “Genocide like this happens when other states provide material support,” he said. “You look at the situation in Myanmar, where they’re clearly getting cover from China and the United States, and further, Russia’s role in Syria. It doesn’t seem like we’ve learned very much”:

Rwanda Accuses France of Complicity in 1994 Genocide

KIGALI, Rwanda — The Rwandan government released an independent report on Wednesday accusing French officials of complicity in the 1994 genocide, risking further strains to already icy relations between the two countries.

The report, commissioned by the Rwandan government and conducted by a Washington law firm, alleges that French military forces trained their Rwandan counterparts, supplied them with weapons even after an arms embargo, and gave cover, under the auspices of a United Nations-sanctioned humanitarian mission, in the last moments of a genocidal campaign.

Researchers and the Rwandan government say they cannot get France to make good on earlier commitments to fully open its archives or otherwise investigate the country’s role.

“What happened in the early ’90s and even before, in the lead-up to the genocide, is something France will have to come to terms with,” said Louise Mushikiwabo, the foreign minister of Rwanda. “Rwanda is not going away. We’re not going anywhere.”

Archival documents show that the French government was a close ally of the Rwandan regime that planned and perpetrated the mass slaughter of an estimated 800,000 people, most of them members of the Tutsi ethnic minority. Historians say a son of François Mitterrand, the French president at the time, was also a close friend of the Rwandan leader whose government organized the genocide.

Some examples of French complicity remain raw 23 years later.

“There were cases where they found Tutsi refugees, saw them, and then left them, and more of them were killed,” said Timothy P. Longman, the director of the African Studies Center at Boston University. “It’s one thing after another. The French absolutely deserve to be condemned.”

The two governments have repeatedly tussled over access to information, in procedural disputes that are part of a larger political drama.

In 2006, a French judge opened an investigation into the 1994 plane crash that killed President Juvenal Habyarimana of Rwanda, a member of the majority Hutu ethnic group. The crash is widely seen as the spark that ignited the genocide, making responsibility for the crash one of the most politically volatile questions in Rwanda.

According to diplomatic cables, French officials at the time blamed the Tutsi rebel army led by Paul Kagame, now Rwanda’s president. Mr. Kagame’s government has long maintained that the plane was shot down by Hutu military actors.

The Rwandans responded to the investigation by severing diplomatic ties with France and initiating their own inquiry into the French role in the genocide. The two countries did not restore diplomatic relations until 2009.

The relationship nevertheless remains fraught. In 2015, France blocked the nomination of Rwanda’s ambassador to the European Union; the country is still waiting for approval of its new appointee for the post, according to Rwandan government officials.

France’s reluctance to prosecute individuals involved in the genocide has further aggravated the situation.

Last year, the Rwandan government asked the French for permission to question some of the 22 French military officers who it said bore some responsibility for the killings. The French government has never replied to that request, said Ms. Mushikiwabo, the foreign minister.

In October, an investigative judge at the Paris Court of Appeal upheld a decision not to investigate two top French military figures in Rwanda for complicity in the genocide. Among the issues raised was alleged French responsibility for the deaths of hundreds of Tutsis at Bisesero, while French troops were present only miles away, according to the International Federation for Human Rights, a Paris-based organization that was party to the case.

Rwandans living in France who are suspected of perpetrating the genocide — including the then-president’s wife, thought to have been a mastermind of the massacres — have also largely escaped prosecution. In 2013, the French government started a special unit for investigating war crimes, but only a few Rwandans have been prosecuted.

Ms. Mushikiwabo said the report was the first step in increasing pressure the Rwandans will bring to bear on the French. The Washington law firm Cunningham Levy Muse, which produced the report, will continue its investigations, Ms. Mushikiwabo said, adding that the Rwandan government was amassing its own archive of contemporary documents, including some left behind by the French.

The report also comes at a time of renewed interest in France’s accountability for suspected crimes abroad. Two weeks ago, during a visit to Burkina Faso, President Emmanuel Macron promised to declassify documents related to the 1987 assassination of that country’s president, Thomas Sankara. Many in Burkina Faso suspect the French of being involved in his death.

But on a visit last week to the former French colony of Algeria, Mr. Macron resisted questions about French atrocities there, insisting that it was time to “look forward.”

Mr. Macron’s predecessor, François Hollande, declassified some documents relating to Rwanda, but French researchers say too much of the primary historical record is still off-limits.

Last month, a French court denied François Graner, a French researcher on Rwanda, access to documents in the archive of Mr. Mitterrand, the French president during the genocide. Mr. Graner plans to appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

Mr. Graner said that basic historical questions about France’s role in Rwanda remained unanswered, and that those questions very likely have far-reaching consequences.

“The Rwanda intervention is the most symbolic of the more than 50 French military interventions in Africa,” Mr. Graner said. French forces are still involved in Africa, he added, and they are deployed “with nearly the same decision-making mechanisms that were at play in Rwanda.”

Toby Cadman, an international criminal lawyer based in London with extensive experience in mass-atrocity trials, said the questions at play also had an impact on global affairs.

“Genocide like this happens when other states provide material support,” he said. “You look at the situation in Myanmar, where they’re clearly getting cover from China and the United States, and we criticize Russia for their role in Syria. It doesn’t seem like we’ve learned very much.”

Some critics say that Rwanda is an imperfect messenger on facing history, given the government’s refusal to acknowledge crimes said to have been committed by the rebel army that ended the genocide.

But Rwandan officials insist that such allegations do not absolve an unrepentant France.

“There was a civil war and a genocide in this country,” said Ms. Mushikiwabo, the foreign minister. “Clearly, it is not possible to conduct war without people dying.”

“If we were to say that yes, there were massacres, there were killings that were a result of the war that the Rwandan Patriotic Army conducted against the then-genocidaire army — that is clear,” she continued, using the official name of the rebels’ military arm at the end of the genocide. “That does not take away the fact that France was part of the planning, part of the conception, and part of the execution of the genocide.”


This article, by Jina Moore, was published at The New York Times on 13th December 2017.

More News

  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-08 a las 18.48.18 Radio SER: “Sin justicia para Siria”

    Radio SER: “Sin justicia para Siria”

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-06 a las 20.45.46 Cherie Blair: “‘Never again’ is becoming a fantasy. Justice does not have to be.”

    Cherie Blair: “‘Never again’ is becoming a fantasy. Justice does not...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-05 a las 20.46.34 ABC News: “Ex-colonel denies role in priests’ slayings in El Salvador”

    ABC News: “Ex-colonel denies role in priests’ slayings in El...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-01 a las 18.05.49 RTVE: Prisión incondicional decretada contra Inocente Orlando Montano

    RTVE: Prisión incondicional decretada contra Inocente Orlando Montano

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-01 a las 17.18.03 El Español: El coronel salvadoreño que ordenó la matanza de cinco jesuitas españoles, a prisión

    El Español: El coronel salvadoreño que ordenó la matanza de cinco jesuitas...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-01 a las 14.23.55 I Am Shawkan

    I Am Shawkan

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-12-01 a las 12.49.13 El Diario.es: Abogados europeos estudian como llevar a la justicia los crimenes de lesa humanidad de la guerra siria

    El Diario.es: Abogados europeos estudian como llevar a la justicia los crimenes...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-11-29 a las 16.15.23 The Guardian: Former El Salvador colonel extradited to Spain over 1989 murder of Jesuits

    The Guardian: Former El Salvador colonel extradited to Spain over 1989 murder of...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-11-29 a las 16.04.23 Cadena SER: España podrá juzgar al inductor del asesinato del jesuíta Ellacuría

    Cadena SER: España podrá juzgar al inductor del asesinato del jesuíta Ellacur...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-09-29 a las 23.01.45 El Mundo: El ex viceministro de Defensa salvadoreño Inocente Montano llega a España para enfrentarse al caso Ellacuría

    El Mundo: El ex viceministro de Defensa salvadoreño Inocente Montano llega a...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-10-19 a las 20.08.21 COMUNICADO DE PRENSA: El coronel salvadoreño Inocente Orlando Montano llega a España extraditado desde Estados Unidos para ser juzgado por su responsabilidad en la masacre de los padres Jesuitas y dos mujeres en El Salvador en 1989.

    COMUNICADO DE PRENSA: El coronel salvadoreño Inocente Orlando Montano llega a...

    Read Story
  • Captura de pantalla 2017-10-19 a las 20.08.21 PRESS STATEMENT: Salvadoran Colonel Inocente Orlando Montano arrives in Madrid in police custody after the conclusion of his extradition process to stand trial for his involvement in the massacre of six Jesuit priests and two women in El Salvador in 1989.

    PRESS STATEMENT: Salvadoran Colonel Inocente Orlando Montano arrives in Madrid...

    Read Story